The Penn State Nittany Lions were playing for a berth in the College Football Playoff national championship in January 2025 and were on the brink of beating the Notre Dame Fighting Irish to get that spot.
Fast forward nearly two years later, the team may have suffered one of its worst losses.
THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!
Penn State was hoping to defend Happy Valley against the Rutgers Scarlet Knights – a team they had beaten every time they had played since 1988. Rutgers had not had much success since moving to the Big Ten Conference but showed signs of life in Greg Schiano’s second stint at head coach. While the 2026 season had gone awry, Rutgers could hang its hat on Saturday’s result.
The Scarlet Knights pulled off an epic comeback to stun the Nittany Lions, 25-24.
It started with an Antwan Raymond 13-yard touchdown run to cut the deficit to 24-17 with 10: 19 left in the game. Rutgers forced Penn State to punt the ball back to them with 1: 37 remaining in the game. Scarlet Knights quarterback A. J. Surace led the team on an 11-play, 67-yard drive to score a touchdown with no time remaining on the clock.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE OUTKICK SPORTS COVERAGE
The play itself was almost as unbelievable as writing "Rutgers beat Penn State."
Surace tossed the ball to Raymond, who was met by a swarm of blue jerseys. Raymond made a heads-up play to pitch the ball to Ben Black III, who scored the touchdown. It brought Rutgers to within one point of the lead.
Schiano determined in that moment there was nothing to lose by going for the win. Surace threw a pass to DK Gilley, who found the end zone and gave Rutgers the absolutely stunning victory.
The 38-year streak is over. You have to give Schiano a ton of credit for laying it all out there and having confidence in the offense to try to gut out the victory in regulation instead of trying to spend any more time in Beaver Stadium than was absolutely necessary.
The 2026 season is absolutely one to forget for Rutgers. But the Scarlet Knights will always have Nov. 21, in which they topped Penn State on the road.

